Every comma decision
Does this spot need a comma? The four jobs a comma does, and the places it never goes.
Don't place a comma by where you'd pause out loud; readers pause in different places. Instead, ask what job the comma would be doing. Joining two complete sentences with a FANBOYS word? Comma before the FANBOYS word. Setting off something the sentence could lose: an opening phrase or clause, an interrupter, an appositive, a nonessential which or who clause, a name you're speaking to? Commas around it (one comma if it's at the start or end). Separating the items in a list, or the parts of a date, address, or quotation? Use the list or format rule. If none of these jobs applies, leave the comma out, and check the never-list: no comma between a subject and its verb, before a FANBOYS word joining only words or phrases, or around a clause the sentence needs.
Joining two complete sentences
Example
Only with a FANBOYS word after it; run the period test on both halves first.
Example
The look-alike that takes no comma, one subject doing two things.
Setting off extra information
Example
Opening elements, interrupters, and direct address all get fenced off.
Term
appositive
Example
Example
Commas around a which/who clause the sentence could lose.
Lists and formats
Example
Where a comma never goes
Example
A clause the sentence needs to identify its noun takes no commas.